The resurgence of Anthony Stolarz has rapidly shifted the considerations for his future. Originally signed as backup for Joseph Woll, the veteran goaltender came in and outshone expectations during the 2024–25 season. Now, the potential contract extension rumors grow louder by the day, and the loudest voices seem to be shouting that the Maple Leafs may be forced into giving him a huge contract, a signing that would greatly change their goaltending landscape for years ahead.
Anthony Stolarz’s impressive form and contract climate point to a major payday
Anthony Stolarz finished his first year in Toronto with a 21-8-3 regular-season record through 34 appearances, backed by an insanely good 0.926 save percentage and a 2.14 goals-against average. These are numbers that, for a backup, are highly exceptional and good for a starter, making him an absolute steal for $2.5 million per annum.With his current contract expiring soon, speculation of a blockbuster long-term extension is ramping up. The former NHL netminder Carter Hutton has recently shed light on the financial landscape for goaltenders of this caliber, highlighting the deals of Lankinen ($22.5 million for four years), Blackwood ($26.25 million for five years), and Vejmelka ($23.75 million for five years). These precedents can allow a deal with Stolarz in the $25–30 million range, especially with his age and injury history working against him and nudging him to choose security in a long-term deal.That said, not everyone in hockey seems ready to see Toronto commit right now. Jay Rosehill, the analyst, advised caution, saying the Maple Leafs should wait and see if Stolarz can duplicate his performance next season. With Joseph Woll starting the first year of a three-year contract averaging $3.6 million per season, any move on Stolarz will have a direct bearing on Toronto’s goaltending allocation, which could be pushed up to nearly $10 million for two netminders each year.Toronto’s front office faces a familiar conundrum: reward a breakout performance or wait for long-term consistency. Stolarz, capable of stepping up to the plate after his win in the 2023-24 Stanley Cup with the Panthers, is now the question. For 32 years, the volatilities of his next contract must be carefully contemplated. Also Read: NHL rumors: Los Angeles Kings interested in Calgary Flames blue-liner Rasmus AnderssonThe status of Stolarz as a top performer in the Gates has created an urgency for contract discussions. Market parallels make an argument for the big extension; however, the Leafs must now decide whether they want to take the player on now or wait until he gives more proof and stake a $25–30 million gamble.
